is a menstrual disc like a diaphragm?
While a menstrual disc and a diaphragm are similar in shape and placement, they serve different purposes.
Here’s a breakdown of how they compare:
Menstrual Disc vs. Diaphragm
Feature |
Menstrual Disc |
Diaphragm |
---|---|---|
Purpose |
Collects menstrual fluid |
Acts as a barrier to prevent pregnancy |
Placement |
Sits at the base of the cervix, high in the vaginal canal |
Covers the cervix, also high in the vaginal canal |
Material |
Medical-grade silicone, TPE |
Silicone or latex |
Insertion |
Folded and inserted, then it opens up |
Inserted with spermicide, covers the cervix |
Wear Time |
Up to 12 hours before needing to be emptied or replaced |
Typically used for 6-8 hours, must be used with spermicide |
Can Be Worn During Sex |
Yes, some designs allow for sex (e.g., my mimi) |
No, it must be removed before sexual intercourse |
Reusable |
Yes, reusable after cleaning |
Typically reusable, but must be cleaned after each use |
Effectiveness |
High capacity, effective for managing menstrual flow |
Effective for contraception when used correctly |
Comfort |
Can be worn comfortably for extended periods |
Must be fitted correctly and might cause discomfort |