Date created: 10 September 2024 · Read time: 5 minutes
Period care comparison
Menstrual Disc vs Tampons: Safety, Comfort & Care
Comparing a menstrual disc vs tampon can help you choose period care that suits your body, flow and lifestyle. Both can be used safely when you follow the product instructions and practise good hygiene.
This guide explains the practical differences between a reusable my mimi menstrual disc and tampons, including placement, materials, cleaning, wear time and when to seek medical advice.
Quick answer
Are menstrual discs safer than tampons?
There is no single “safest” period product for everyone. Tampons and menstrual discs each have different benefits and care requirements. Tampons have a known association with the rare condition toxic shock syndrome (TSS), while reusable internal products should also be used exactly as directed, kept clean and removed within their recommended wear time.
At a glance
How a menstrual disc differs from a tampon
A menstrual disc collects period fluid inside the vagina. It sits higher in the vaginal canal, below the cervix, and is held in place by resting behind the pubic bone.
A tampon sits lower in the vaginal canal and absorbs menstrual fluid. The better option is the one that feels comfortable, fits your needs and is used according to its instructions.
What is a menstrual disc? →
Menstrual discs vs tampons: key differences
01
TSS and hygiene
TSS is rare but serious. It has a known association with tampon use, particularly when a tampon is left in too long. Follow all product instructions, use good hand hygiene and seek urgent medical care if you develop sudden flu-like symptoms, fever, rash, vomiting or dizziness.
02
How they manage flow
Tampons absorb flow. A menstrual disc collects it. Some people prefer collecting products because they do not absorb vaginal moisture, while others prefer the familiarity and simplicity of tampons.
03
Placement and removal
A disc is inserted horizontally towards the tailbone and tucked behind the pubic bone. Tampons sit lower in the vaginal canal and are removed using a string. Both can take practise at first.
04
Materials
Reusable menstrual discs are commonly made from medical-grade silicone or similar body-safe materials. Tampons are commonly made from cotton, rayon or a blend. Check packaging if you have sensitivities or prefer fragrance-free options.
05
Cleaning and replacement
Tampons are single-use and need changing regularly. A reusable disc needs rinsing during your cycle when appropriate, plus cleaning and sterilising according to the brand’s instructions before storage.
06
Waste and long-term value
A reusable menstrual disc can reduce the number of disposable period products you use over time. Tampons are convenient and widely available, but they create single-use waste after each use.
Safety first
Use any internal period product as directed
Read the instructions that come with your product, wash your hands before insertion and removal, and do not exceed the recommended wear time. A disc should feel comfortable once it is correctly positioned; pain, pressure or ongoing discomfort are reasons to remove it and reassess.
Follow instructions
Use the recommended wear time and care method.
Keep hands clean
Wash before inserting or removing any internal product.
Listen to your body
Stop using it if you have pain, irritation or unusual symptoms.
Get medical help
Seek urgent care for possible TSS symptoms or severe pain.
Using a disc
How to use a menstrual disc
Pinch the disc into a narrow shape, guide it in horizontally towards your tailbone, then tuck the front rim behind your pubic bone. When the fit is right, it should feel secure and almost unnoticeable.
The my mimi menstrual disc includes a loop tab intended to support removal. Take your time while learning, especially during your first few cycles.
Read the step-by-step guide →
Finding your fit
Choosing the right menstrual disc size
Fit can influence comfort, leak protection and how securely a disc stays in place. Your age, vaginal birth history, cervix height, flow and personal comfort can all be useful considerations.
my mimi has Small and Large options, supported by a size guide to help you narrow down the right starting point.
Find your size →
Why people consider reusable menstrual discs
Comfort
No absorbent feel
Because a disc collects fluid rather than absorbing it, some users prefer how it feels compared with absorbent products.
Flexibility
Made for everyday movement
With the right fit and placement, a menstrual disc can suit work, sport, sleep, swimming and day-to-day activity.
Less waste
Reusable period care
A reusable disc can be used cycle after cycle when cleaned and cared for according to the brand’s instructions.
Helpful next reads
Explore practical guides before deciding whether a menstrual disc is right for you.
Ready to explore?
Meet the my mimi reusable menstrual disc
Soft medical-grade silicone, a suction-free design and two size options to support a more confident period routine.
Shop the menstrual disc →
Health note: This page provides general information only and is not a substitute for medical advice. Speak with a qualified health professional if you have ongoing pain, irritation, unusual symptoms, concerns about product suitability, or possible symptoms of toxic shock syndrome.